You don't have to travel to a Harry Potter theme park to enjoy Butterbeer! Here's how you can make it at home, with just a few ingredients.
Do you ever wish that you could visit the magical lands that you read about in books?
I'm kind of obsessed with fictional stories, and my imagination can get a bit carried away while I'm reading. This usually means that when one of my favourite books gets adapted into a film, I'm disappointed by what I see on the screen.
Luckily, this wasn't the case with the Harry Potter films. The sets and scenery were very close to what I had imagined - which I'm sure is largely due to the fact that J.K. Rowling is a wonderful writer. I loved being able to immerse myself into her magical world through both the books and the film. So when a Harry Potter themed Island of Adventure opened in Florida, I was excited! I would actually be able to see that world in real life! You can even taste some of the Harry Potter foods at the park, including a frothy chilled version of Butterbeer!
That attraction opened in 2010, and since then two more Harry Potter attractions have opened up (with a fourth under construction).
And I haven't visited any of them.
Sadly, traveling to see those attractions just hasn't been in my budget. Also, deep down inside I think I'm afraid that I will be disappointed. My last trip to Disneyland was underwhelming, filled with hours spent waiting in line and fighting through crowds. That just isn't my idea of fun.
So maybe I'm better off sticking to my book and films, and making my own version of the Harry Potter treats. Besides, a friend told me that he got seriously ill after drinking the frozen Butterbeer at the park, so maybe I dodged a bullet there!
Have you noticed that the flavour of Butterbeer isn't written anywhere in the Harry Potter books? It's left to your imagination - and I've always imagined that it would be something like a frothy hot toddy! That's what I had in mind when I came up with this recipe.
I started with buttered rum for the base, but I didn't want to put actual butter in the drink. So I replaced the butter and sugar with this homemade butterscotch sauce recipe from my friend Karyn (which you will want to eat on everything because it's delicious!). That took care of the "butter" part. I also didn't want to use actual beer in the drink. So I opted for an old-fashioned cream soda to add fizz and caramel flavour to the drink. You could use a clear cream soda, but I prefer the flavour of a dark cream soda like Virgil's Cream Soda.
The mixture tasted good, but it was missing something. And it didn't have any froth on top! To fix this problem, I added a little bit of vanilla ice cream, which not only added some foam but also rounded out the flavour of the entire drink. Success!
"'Tell you what,' said Ron, his teeth chattering, 'shall we go for a Butterbeer in the Three Broomsticks?'
Harry and Hermione made their way to the back of the room, where there was a small, vacant table between the window and a handsome Christmas tree, which stood next to the fireplace. Ron came back five minutes later, carrying three foaming tankards of hot Butterbeer.
Harry drank deeply. It was the most delicious thing he’d ever tasted and seemed to heat every bit of him from the inside."
🖨 Printable Recipe
- 2 tablespoon butterscotch sauce
- 1 teaspoon boiling water, , (can be used to dissolve butterscotch if needed)
- 1 teaspoon dark rum, , optional (adjust quantity to taste)
- 355 millilitres Virgil's Cream Soda, , at room temperature
- 1 tablespoon vanilla ice cream
- Add butterscotch sauce to glass. If the sauce has been in the fridge, you will need to add the boiling water as well.
- Add the rum (if using), and stir to combine with the butterscotch sauce.
- Pour in the soda, and give the mixture a quick stir to combine. If you stir too much, you will lose the carbonation of the drink.
- Add the ice cream, and stir briefly until a foam forms on top of the drink.
- Serve immediately.
For a more intense beverage:
- Warm the mixture in the microwave for about 30 seconds, then add the ice cream.
Please read the blog post for detailed tips and explanations.
Nutrition Disclaimer: this nutritional information is only an estimate. The accuracy of this information cannot be guaranteed.
This is not a sponsored post. This post contains Amazon affiliate links.
Quote taken from Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban, Chapter 10
This looks so delicious! I've been wanting to try a Butterbeer recipe! My husband and I will have to make this next time we binge watch HP!
Thanks Logan, I hope you do try it!
I have never made butterbeer, but this looks awesome! Thanks so much for using my butterscotch recipe in it. It is an magical elixir!
Your butterscotch recipe is SO MUCH BETTER than the store-bought stuff! It worked perfectly in this drink!
Oh how I love Harry Potter! <3 This is the perfect drink for fall and winter, love it!!!
Amanda | The Cinnamon Scrolls
Hi Shareba! It was wonderful to meet you last weekend, albeit briefly! You have a fantastic blog here! I feel like you and I are in the same boat here. I'm a huge Potterhead, but haven't been able to visit any of the parks either! It's so sad. And I totally agree that I thought Butterbeer would taste like a frothy hot toddy but with a bit more vanilla flavour. Not sure why! Anyway, this looks fab and I'll definitely be making it sometime this winter! Talk soon! 🙂
Hey Amanda, it was nice to meet you too! The conference went by so quickly!!
I totally agree with you about the vanilla! Virigil's Cream Soda is actually made with vanilla beans, so it add vanilla flavour to the drink. The vanilla ice cream also helps lol.
It's like you took the words out of my head. This is exactly how I feel about characters, I get really immersed into the story and then I miss all the characters like real friends once the story is done. And Also, I feel the same about Harry Potter universe. I read the books many times and I saw the movies more than once. I also dream of going to the HP theme park. Your Butterbeer is lovely and kudos on the magic wand! Better than my chopstick that I used in place of a wand 6 years ago for my HP recipe (https://www.imagelicious.com/blog/post/harry-potters-favourite-treacle-tart)
I go through withdrawal when I finish a good book - I hate saying goodbye to the characters! The wand is actually from the theme park! I knew my friend bought one when she visited, and she was kind enough to lend it to me for the photos 🙂
Lily @Gastro Senses
Ok – this may have to replace my usual Xmas morning drink! Yum!
Ooh, what do you usually have? I think you'll like this, but just know that it's very sweet 😉