Easy and Delicious Tea Sandwich Recipes

From bridal showers to Mother’s Day celebrations to cozy afternoon teas, there’s something undeniably special about serving a tray of dainty, flavourful sandwiches.

This collection of tea sandwich recipes includes my personal favourites along with tasty ideas from fellow food bloggers—perfect for creating a memorable and elegant spread.

These tea sandwich recipes have been thoughtfully selected for their balance of flavour, ease of preparation, and crowd-pleasing appeal.

From timeless classics like cucumber and smoked salmon to fun, creative twists like pimento cheese and strawberry, each recipe brings a special pop of flavour to the table.

Pro Tips for Delicious Tea Sandwiches:

• Always use soft, thinly sliced bread. White, whole wheat, rye and Pumpernickel are all good options.
• Trim crusts for a more elegant presentation.
• Don't overfill your sandwiches, or they won't cut nicely.
• Always serve your sandwiches at room temperature.
• If you're making your sandwiches ahead of an event, wrap them in wax paper and place them under a damp towel to prevent them from drying out.

What Tea to Serve with Tea Sandwiches

No afternoon tea is complete without a warm pot of freshly brewed tea.

Classic black teas like Earl Grey, Darjeeling, Orange Pekoe or English Breakfast are always a hit with savoury sandwiches, while herbal blends like chamomile or mint pair nicely with lighter or vegetarian options.

If you're new to brewing tea, check out these helpful guides:

• A Beginner’s Guide to Loose Leaf Tea: Learn about different types of tea and how to choose the right one for your taste.
• How to Make Loose Leaf Tea: Step-by-step instructions for brewing a perfect cup.

7 Tea Sandwich Recipes Your Guests Will Love

I love serving these easy tea sandwich recipes at cozy gatherings because they feel elegant but are incredibly simple to make.

Pimento Cheese Tea Sandwiches

These pimento cheese tea sandwiches are one of my favourite additions to an afternoon tea menu. They’re bold, creamy, tangy, and totally crave-worthy—something a little different from the usual delicate tea sandwich.

MAKE THIS RECIPE

Cucumber and Herb Tea Sandwiches

Put a twist on a classis with these cucumber and herb tea sandwiches from Season & Serve. Featuring a creamy spread made with cream cheese, mayonnaise and fresh herbs, they offer a vibrant, savoury flavour. Thinly sliced cucumbers are layered on top of the sandwiches, creating an elegant presentation.

MAKE THIS RECIPE

Photo credit: seasonandserveblog.com

Smoked Salmon Tea Sandwiches

A good tea sandwich doesn't need to be complicated, but the flavour boost in these smoked salmon tea sandwiches is worth the extra ingredients. The lemon-caper-dill cream cheese filling pairs beautifully with silky smoked salmon and soft pumpernickel bread.

MAKE THIS RECIPE

Ham and Cheese Tea Sandwiches

These ham and cheese tea sandwiches from The Cup of Life are a quick and satisfying option, ready in just 10 minutes. Featuring layers of thinly sliced Black Forest ham and sharp cheddar cheese, complemented by a creamy mayonnaise and mustard spread, they're easy to assemble and full of flavour.

MAKE THIS RECIPE

Photo credit: theteacupoflife.com

Turkey Salad & Cranberry Tea Sandwiches

These turkey salad tea sandwiches from Big Flavors from a Tiny Kitchen offer a delightful twist with the addition of dried cherries. The recipe combines finely chopped poached turkey, celery, green onions, and a touch of white wine vinegar, all bound together with creamy mayonnaise for a flavour-packed bite.

MAKE THIS RECIPE

Photo credit: bigflavorstinykitchen.com

Herbed Avocado Egg Salad Tea Sandwiches

These herbed avocado egg salad tea sandwiches from Simple Bites offer a fresh, mayo-free twist on a classic. Grated hard-boiled eggs are combined with creamy avocado, finely diced celery, crème fraîche, and fresh herbs. Layered on whole wheat bread and topped with peppery sprouts, these sandwiches deliver a healthy balance of textures and flavours.

MAKE THIS RECIPE

Photo credit: simplebites.net

Strawberry Tea Sandwiches

These strawberry tea sandwiches from The Cup of Life are a delightful blend of creamy and sweet flavours. Made with just three ingredients—they come together in about 10 minutes. The slight tang of the cream cheese complements the natural sweetness of the strawberries, creating a simple yet elegant bite.

MAKE THIS RECIPE